For years, the message that has reached the public has been simple: sugar is bad. And like almost every simple message, it is partly true and partly unfair. The true part is that people eat too much sugar, especially hidden in processed products. The unfair part is that the spotlight has ended up on craft sweets, which are eaten in different amounts, in a different context and with different ingredients.
This article is not medical advice. It is a reflection for those who make their living from sweet things: what the recommendations say, why swapping sugar for sweetener is not enough and what a pastry shop can do to tell its story better.
What the recommendations really say
The World Health Organization does not say sugar must be eliminated. Its 2015 guideline is about free sugars: those added to food and those found in honey, syrups and fruit juices. It recommends they do not exceed 10% of daily energy intake and suggests going down to 5% for additional benefits.
The key lies in the word “free” and in the total amount. The health problem is not caused by a Sunday cake, but by the daily sum of soft drinks, packaged juices, sauces, sugary cereals, industrial baked goods and processed products in which sugar turns up where nobody expects it.
Why the message hurts craft pastry
When the message is reduced to “sugar is bad”, consumers do not distinguish between a packaged industrial pastry and a piece of patisserie made that morning with butter, eggs and fruit. They lump them together. And since craft sweets are the ones bought consciously, they are the ones that take the blame.
The result is a customer who walks into the pastry shop feeling they are doing something wrong, or who stops coming in. Meanwhile, the sugar hidden in processed food goes unnoticed.
Sweeteners are not a magic solution
Much of the industry has responded by replacing sugar with sweeteners. They are authorised and assessed in the European Union (Regulation (EC) 1333/2008 on food additives), but that does not make them the answer to everything:
- They do not help with long-term weight control. In 2023, the WHO published a guideline advising against using non-sugar sweeteners for that purpose.
- They do not replace sugar in the workshop. Sugar does more than sweeten: it gives volume and structure to meringues and sponges, retains water and extends shelf life, feeds fermentation, gives colour in the oven and texture to creams and ice cream. Most sweeteners do not do all of that.
- They change the product. Flavour, texture and behaviour in the oven are different. A reformulated traditional recipe is no longer the same recipe.
This does not mean sugar cannot be reduced. It means it has to be done recipe by recipe, testing, and not as a change of label.
Quantity, quality and context
The sugar dissolved in a drink taken every day is not the same as the sugar in a quality dessert eaten now and then in a reasonable portion. Three ideas help put it in its place:
- Quantity. A portion of pastry is not a main course. Smaller formats (minis, individual portions) let people enjoy without overdoing it.
- Quality. Butter instead of hydrogenated fats, real fruit, quality chocolate: craft sweets have arguments on their side.
- Context. A varied diet and an active life leave room for the pleasure of a good sweet treat. Pastry is culture, celebration and craft.
What a pastry shop can do
The sweet sector has said little about what it does, and said it badly, and others have filled that space. Some ideas to turn it around:
- Inform with data, not slogans. A clear nutrition table says how much sugar a portion contains. Transparency builds trust. If you pre-pack, it is also mandatory: we explain it in nutrition labelling for pastry shops and bakeries.
- Say what you leave out. If you do not use hydrogenated fats, unnecessary preservatives or colourings, say so. For you it is normal; for the customer, it may not be.
- Offer different portion sizes. Small formats and slices let people enjoy without guilt.
- Reformulate wisely. If you want a lower-sugar version, test, adjust and recalculate its nutrition information. And be careful with claims: “no added sugars” or “low sugar” have specific conditions in Regulation (EC) 1924/2006.
- Use the label as a selling point. A professional label with ingredients, allergens and nutrition information conveys care. We discuss it in how labelling affects sales.
Knowing how much sugar each piece contains
To communicate with data, you need to have it. In Recipok, the nutrition information of each recipe is calculated from its ingredients, with sugars shown separately from the rest of the carbohydrate, and appears on the label and the technical sheet. If you reformulate to reduce sugar, you duplicate the recipe, change the quantities and see instantly how the nutrition table and the cost change. More in nutrition information.
In short: yes to sugar, in the right measure
Sugar is neither poison nor innocent. The problem is the total amount and the sugar hidden in processed food, not well-made, sensibly sized craft sweets. Pastry has good arguments: quality, craft and transparency. It just needs to tell them.